Can Silver Coated Dressing Prevent Surgical Site Infections
in Elderly with Hip Fractures – A Randomized prospective Trial
Assaf Kadar, Ety Yahav, Gilad Eisenberg, Moshe Salai
Background
Surgical site infections (SSI) after hip fracture
surgery are a common complication with serious consequences both for the
patient and the medical system that treats him. Silver ions are a known
anti-bacterial agent; yet, the use of silver dressing in the primary prevention
of surgical wound infections is controversial. We conduct a randomized
controlled trial to compare silver dressing (SD) with regular dressing (RD) in
the prevention of SSI in elderly patients undergoing surgery for hip fractures,
and compare costs.
Methods
A matched group of 55 Patients with hip fractures
undergoing surgery with dynamic hip screw, cephalomedullary nail or
hemiarthroplasty were randomized to either silver dressing (n=31) or regular
dressing (n=24) groups. The dressings were applied in the operating theater and
the patients were followed for one week for clinical signs of infection
(discharge, erythema and fever). Additionally, skin swabs were taken from the
wound surface on day 5-7 post operative for bacterial skin colonization. The
use of SD was according to the manufacturer instruction, i.e. they were not
removed for 5-7 days and kept moist.
Results
There were no significant differences between the SD
and RD groups with regard to age, sex or co-morbidities. 2 of 31 (6.4%) patients in the silver dressing group had signs of infection
compared to 2 of 24 (8.3%) in the regular dressing group (p=1). Skin
colonization by bacteria at day 5-7 post-operative was higher in the silver
dressing group with 12 of 19 (63%) patients with positive skin swab, as
compared to 50% in the regular dressing group (p=0.67). additional costs for
the use of SD were ~5.5 US$ per patient.
Conclusion
The use of silver dressing is associated with higher costs;
yet, it was not superior to regular dressing in preventing surgical site
infections in patients undergoing hemiarthroplasty or fixation of hip fractures.
Additionally, silver dressing was not effective in reducing bacterial skin
colonization following the aforementioned injury and operation.
Table I: General patients demographic, co-morbidities and the chance to
develop an infection according to type of dressing used (Silver dressing or
regular dressing)
|
|
Whole Cohort (N=55)
|
Silver Dressing (N=31)
|
Regular Dressing (N=24)
|
p-value
|
|
General Patients' Demographics
|
||||
|
Male/Female
|
18/37
|
11/20
|
7/17
|
0.77ǂ
|
|
Age (SD)
|
79.6 (12.37)
|
80.2 (12.54)
|
78.83 (12.36)
|
0.66*
|
|
Type of surgery (ORIF/Hemiarthroplasty)
|
38/17
|
23/8
|
15/9
|
0.39ǂ
|
|
Co-morbidities
|
||||
|
Hypertension (%)
|
29 (52%)
|
15 (48%)
|
14 (58%)
|
0.58ǂ
|
|
Diabetes (%)
|
9 (16%)
|
7 (22%)
|
2 (8.3%)
|
0.27ǂ
|
|
Heart Disease (%)
|
23 (41%)
|
9 (29%)
|
14 (58%)
|
0.052ǂ
|
|
CVA (%)
|
8 (14%)
|
2 (6%)
|
6 (25%)
|
0.06ǂ
|
|
COPD (%)
|
6 (10%)
|
4 (13%)
|
2 (8.3%)
|
0.68ǂ
|
|
Tracers of post operative infection
|
||||
|
Positive Skin culture 5-7 days post
operative (%)
|
16/27 (59%)
|
12 (63%)
|
4 (50%)
|
0.67ǂ
|
|
Signs of infection (%)
|
4/55 (7.2%)
|
2 (6.4%)
|
2 (8.3%)
|
1ǂ
|
ǂ
Fisher exact test
* Student unpaired t-test
ORIF, open reduction and internal fixation (Dynamic hip screw and
cephalomedullary nail); CVA, Cerebrovascular accident; COPD, Chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease